I am a writer, developer, futurist, and one-half of the Knotty Geeks podcast.

Interests: Astronomy, newLISP, Science Fiction.

User: Password: | Create new account

Canada is purchasing the wrong ZIG.

Jump to page: 1 - 2 - 3 -

AuthorMessage
Riso Posted on: Thu May 3 14:44:45 2012

Joined: Fri Jan 21 04:43:46 2011
Postcount: 3303
Rank: Commodore

Achievements:

We know the F35 is not even in production to be a disaster, but look at the latest F22 problems:

http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-fighter-pilots-20120502,0,1192307.story

Some of the nation’s top aviators are refusing to fly the radar-evading F-22 Raptor, a fighter jet with ongoing problems with the oxygen systems that have plagued the fleet for four years.

At the risk of significant reprimand — or even discharge from the Air Force — fighter pilots are turning down the opportunity to climb into the cockpit of the F-22, the world’s most expensive fighter jet.
Jeremy Reimer Posted on: Thu May 3 14:53:48 2012

Joined: Fri Nov 19 10:21:20 2010
Postcount: 9105
Rank: First Lord of the Admiralty

Achievements:

I don’t blame the pilots for not wanting to fly the F22. Oxygen deprivation and carbon monoxide poisoning can cause permanent brain damage.

AllYorBaseRBelong2Us Posted on: Thu May 3 21:36:10 2012

Joined: Sun Dec 5 06:23:12 2010
Postcount: 10365
Rank: Admiral

Achievements:

How can that not be solvable?

Riso Posted on: Tue May 8 04:53:30 2012

Joined: Fri Jan 21 04:43:46 2011
Postcount: 3303
Rank: Commodore

Achievements:

I don’t know if non-Goons can read this at the moment, buthttp://forums.somethingawful.com/showthread.php?threadid=3483296 lists all the issues Canada has with the F-35.
Jeremy Reimer Posted on: Tue May 8 13:49:16 2012

Joined: Fri Nov 19 10:21:20 2010
Postcount: 9105
Rank: First Lord of the Admiralty

Achievements:

It’s a good thread (I was able to read it) and it sums up all the basic problems.

To me, a more worrying problem seems to be that the cost of designing and building modern fighters seems to be increasing faster than the ability of nations to pay for them.

The F-22 was finally killed due to cost overruns and the F-35, despite being politically unkillable, is going to have its production delayed and then scaled back.

This was never a problem in the days of the F-16 and F-18. Nations just figured out how many they needed and bought them. It wasn’t a big deal.

To me, the whole point of technology is that it gets cheaper and better. If it only gets more expensive and you get less and less of it, why are we even bothering? How the hell are we supposed to get our flying cars at this rate?
AllYorBaseRBelong2Us Posted on: Thu May 17 01:50:20 2012

Joined: Sun Dec 5 06:23:12 2010
Postcount: 10365
Rank: Admiral

Achievements:

"It’s a good thread (I was able to read it) and it sums up all the basic problems.

To me, a more worrying problem seems to be that the cost of designing and building modern fighters seems to be increasing faster than the ability of nations to pay for them."

Wait until we have to defend our satelites. Suborbital Scramjets are silly expensive, except for AYB.

The F-22 was finally killed due to cost overruns and the F-35, despite being politically unkillable, is going to have its production delayed and then scaled back.


The F-22’s costs were by then well known when it was cut. I attribute it’s termination based more off ideals and vision rather than just plain affordabilty.

"This was never a problem in the days of the F-16 and F-18. Nations just figured out how many they needed and bought them. It wasn’t a big deal."

Yeah, and it’ll only get worse. It used to be that warplanes were built by enterprising bicycle repairmen.

"To me, the whole point of technology is that it gets cheaper and better. If it only gets more expensive and you get less and less of it, why are we even bothering? How the hell are we supposed to get our flying cars at this rate? "

There is some truth to that. Considering that the F22 is multple times as effective as an F15 in a lot of projectable roles, it could actually indeed be cheaper.
AllYorBaseRBelong2Us Posted on: Thu May 17 01:51:13 2012

Joined: Sun Dec 5 06:23:12 2010
Postcount: 10365
Rank: Admiral

Achievements:

Wait until we have to defend space from satelite hunting scramjets. that will be ridiculously expensive on both ends!!
AllYorBaseRBelong2Us Posted on: Thu May 17 01:52:07 2012

Joined: Sun Dec 5 06:23:12 2010
Postcount: 10365
Rank: Admiral

Achievements:

we will be talking about 10 billion dollar scramjets, not accounting for inflation.
Riso Posted on: Thu May 17 01:54:53 2012

Joined: Fri Jan 21 04:43:46 2011
Postcount: 3303
Rank: Commodore

Achievements:

10 billion $ scramjets destroyed by 10 million $ missiles. Woo!
Jump to page: 1 - 2 - 3 -