< Back to OSY 1.0 thread list

OSY 1.0 Thread Viewer

Thread #: 1960

Jeremy have you tried silk from unsanity?

OscarWilde

Tue Jun 11 06:54:05 2002

damn the AA has spoilt me. Its a bit blurry and the AA in IE sometimes looks like a newspaper fade, i.e. the text seems to fade from light to dark across the page.

have you tried it? whats your opinion on it?
and how does windows xp cleartype compare if you have tried it that as well? I want your opinions because you're a lot more objective.

off course now i must ask, how does one enable cleartype in XP? i want to try on my friends workstation. Plus does win2k have AA? and how do i enable that?

DeAthe

Tue Jun 11 10:46:12 2002

To enable cleartype in XP go to the display properties ( by control panel, or right clicking on desktop ) hit the appearance tab, then hit the button called effects. Under "use the following method to smooth on screen fonts" select clear type.

And no, cleartype is not available under 2k.

Evil Merlin

Tue Jun 11 11:27:15 2002

If you are running over 1024x768 I tend to notice ClearType is a bit wasted on the resolution. The biggest changes are seen in 800x600 and 1024x768 in my opinion. At higher resolutions, I really don't think there is a need to AA text...

Mind you this is just my opinion.

OscarWilde

Tue Jun 11 12:09:56 2002

800x600? 1024x768? these are resolutions? yikes!

i'm running at a crappy 1280x1024 but only because at higher res i get below 85hz and that is unacceptable to me.

Anyway... is cleartype AA tech or what i hear as LCD font smoothing tech?

AA on the mac tends to make the text bolder and a tad blurry. However the beauty (lost upon pc users due to beige boxes and crappy UI ;) ) makes me want to do naughty stuff that involves pants down, a hand and an errection. I could provide more details if required, just ask and I will be pleased to oblige.

Anyway, thanks DeAthe, i shall return the favour to you one day, which involves the above said naughty stuff with the exception of hands (or hands if you are willing to lend a hand, pun intended).

ah so silly am i.

Jeremy Reimer

Tue Jun 11 16:03:21 2002

I like Cleartype and I run at 1024x768 most of the time.

What is this silk you are talking about?

OscarWilde

Tue Jun 11 16:24:17 2002

www.haxies.com
http://www.haxies.com/silk/

download silk. it installs a system preference 'app'. (you don't have to restart after installing) If you are using IE then just quit IE and then start it up again. Mozilla just requires a new window.  It basically gives AA to almost all carbon apps. When you download it you'll know what i mean.

HitScan

Tue Jun 11 17:20:42 2002

Hurray for OSX! It allows people who know what they're doing to fix Apple's problems!

:D

Jeremy Reimer

Tue Jun 11 19:56:44 2002

10.1.5 is supposed to give AA to "supported" Carbon apps.  An update to Office.X is pending that will integrate with this.  I think I'll wait for the official stuff, just in case the unofficial stuff breaks once the official stuff is finally released. :)
OscarWilde

Wed Jun 12 02:14:58 2002

from HitScan posted at 1:20 am on June 12, 2002

Hurray for OSX! It allows people who know what they're doing to fix Apple's problems!

:D

well here is a quote from a dood at xlr8yourmac:


In this particular case, the feature being exploited is that 10.1.5 and later now allow Carbon apps to request CoreGraphics font rendering even when drawing fonts through QuickDraw APIs. (It was actually already possible to get CoreGraphics font rendering in Carbon apps by using the more modern ATSUI API to draw text, but many apps have enough legacy QuickDraw code that switching to ATSUI is hard.)

I'd guess that Silk does something along the lines of installing a shim library which sits between the real Carbon libraries and Carbon applications, forcing all Carbon apps which use QuickDraw for text to request CG text rendering. This may break some apps, but the breakage will usually be fairly innocuous: mostly I'd expect minor visual glitches, such as lines of text being wider or narrower than the app was written to expect.

Apple is not going to force this new feature on all apps for the simple reason that it violates previously defined behavior. From Apple's POV the only way to do it right is to make it a new feature that must be explicitly enabled by the app, allowing developers to adopt it *after* they've had the chance to iron out any wrinkles it may introduce.

Of all people, I expected you to know how hard it is to implement something and at the sametime expect developers to modify code depending on the difficulties of the port. :)

Jeremy, its a simple matter of removing the two files for this 'hack'. And as for breaking stuff, well so far the peeps at xlr8yourmac and mac achia have been testing silk for your benifit and as of now it seems to work pretty well across the board with little problems other then with apps like AIM which is now fixed with 1.1
Try it out, i knowits hard to escape from the windows paradigm where installing stuff means uninstalling can be a bitch sometimes, but you're using a mac which is after all easy to use... ;)

Seriously, just download the damn thing, install it! You don't have to restart, its enabled straight away. Mess around with it, give me your damn opinions. And if you're uncomfortable, just remove the two files thats detailed in the readme. Thats it, just 5 minutes of your life.
And you're right, 10.1.5 does give AA to supported carbon apps, but as i quoted above, it depends if the developers have a patch that takes advantage of it. Mozilla looks so pretty i tell ya. Oh and if you do have probs with some apps, you can choose in the system prefernce which apps will not be effected by silk. Its all so easy...

Can i get AA in Windows ME?
And there is NO AA is win2k? :( I don't feel like spending money to upgrade Win2k to XP when there is little reason to do so. I might install XP on this laptop running ME. hmmmm....

Jeremy Reimer

Wed Jun 12 02:38:00 2002

98, ME and 2k have antialiasing.  Even Windows 95 with the Plus Pack had it.

Only XP has Cleartype, though.  I like Cleartype.

OscarWilde

Wed Jun 12 02:56:11 2002

they do? where the hell is it? why does IE look like the fonts have been drawn by a two year old?

and have you tried silk? damn it! DO IT!

grrr!!!!

:D

Jeremy Reimer

Wed Jun 12 03:30:33 2002

You actually have to go turn the AA on in 98, ME, 2k.  It's off by default.
OscarWilde

Wed Jun 12 03:33:17 2002

well how?

and have you tried silk yet? or do i have to fly to canada and make you try it?

jdsmith575

Wed Jun 12 03:45:41 2002

I'm using Silk.  It is true goodness.

X.1.5 + Mozilla 1.0 + Navzilla theme + Silk = browsing nirvana

Jeremy Reimer

Wed Jun 12 03:46:50 2002

It's in the display properties panel, under "Effects".  It's called "Smooth edges of screen fonts" or something.

My iBook is rarely connected to the Internet, but when it is, I'll try this silly thing.  Will it help Word.X as well?

OscarWilde

Wed Jun 12 03:50:21 2002

yes it should work for word.x if its a carbon app which obviously it is. :)
OscarWilde

Wed Jun 12 03:53:23 2002

smooth edges of screen fonts does't really do much at all. IE still looks like a hairy donkey's ass.
Jeremy Reimer

Wed Jun 12 04:14:39 2002

It turns off smoothing under a certain point size.  You can adjust this with Windows PowerToys, I think.

Cleartype is awesome.

jdsmith575

Wed Jun 12 04:30:57 2002

Actually, if you update Office v.X, then X.1.5 does the smoothing itself.  It is one of the apps that has been updated to take use of the feature.  Apps that haven't (Mozilla) use silk for AA.

On a side note, I have always doubted MS's commitment to the Mac, even the Mac BU. I think it is interesting to see the Office v.X updater, that takes use of the AA feature in X.1.5, released a day or so X.1.5. It makes me think that at least the BU cares, and they must be working with Apple in some regards. Especially to implement a feature they could have easily waited until Jaguar for, and gotten away with.

PaulHill

Wed Jun 12 07:36:40 2002


It makes me think that at least the BU cares, and they must be working with Apple in some regards.

Well yes, Office for Macintosh is about a billion dollars a year.

Microsoft is all about making money. And protecting the things that make them money, natch.

Evil Merlin

Wed Jun 12 10:40:31 2002

As any real company should...

Why can't the Open Source based companies figure this out?

Magus

Wed Jun 12 15:08:14 2002

Because they're a bunch of idealists who haven't been smacked with reality?
HitScan

Wed Jun 12 18:35:02 2002

Of all people, I expected you to know how hard it is to implement something and at the sametime expect developers to modify code depending on the difficulties of the port. :)

Of course, I was being somewhat teh funneh. :) However, what they should have done is modify the quickdraw API funcs just enough to AA text. It should be optional I suppose, but if it's done in a way that doesn't break anything old (I don't see what can be broken unless some t00l dev did his UI pixel perfect to the edge of his fontage.) The way ClearType works, it can at most be 1 pixel larger on both sides. The spacing between letters does not change. (I did a quick test in paint, it's pretty interesting.) So, it could be done, but I agree that it would probly be better in apps that planned for it.